Republic of the Philippines

House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal

HRET CASE 2019 - 2022

CASE NUMBER

PARTICULARS

STATUS OF CASE

19-001

Andres A. Eligan,Jr. -v.- Maria Loudes O. Acosta-Alba   /  5th District, Bukidnon

DENIED for filing out of time and lack of merit

19-002

Sol F. Matugas -v.- Robert Ace Barbers   /  2nd District, Surigao del Norte

DISMISSED

19-003

Arnold I. Atienza -v.- Amanda Christina L. Bagatsing    /  5th District, Manila

DISMISSED per Protestant's Motion to Withdraw

19-004

Francisco J. Tito -v.- Manuel E. Zamora   /  1st District, Davao de Oro

DISMISSED per Protestant's Motion to Withdraw

19-005

Farouk A. Macarambon,Jr. -v.- Yasser A. Balindong   /  2nd District, Lanao del Sur

DISMISSED without further proceedings

19-006

Benjamin Asilo -v.- Manuel Luis T. Lopez   /  1st District, Manila

DISMISSED due to insufficiency in form and substance per Rule 17 of the 2015 HRET Rules , as ammended.

19-007

Eugene Michael B. De Vera -v.- Stella Luz A. Quimbo   /  2nd District,  Marikina City

DISMISSED for being moot and academic

19-008

Marilou F. Murillo -v.- Paulino Salvador C. Leachon   /  1st District, Mindoro Province

DISMISSED per Protestant's Motion to Withdraw

19-009

Mary Elizabeth Ortiga-Ty -v.- Prospero Arreza Pichay,Jr.   /  1st District, Surigao del Sur

DISMISSED in a Resolution promulgated on February 11, 2021

19-010

 

Roberto T. Uy,Jr. -v.- Romeo Jalosjos,Jr.   /  !st District, Zamboanga del Norte

DISMISSED per Protestant's Motion to Withdraw

19-011/19-014

 

Philip Hernandez Piccio -v.- Rossana Vergara Vergara ; Czarina D. Umali -v.- Rossana Vergara Vergara    /  3rd District, Nueva Ecija

DISMISSED in Decision promulgated on June 09, 2022

19-012

 

Thomas M. Orbos -v.- Thomas Del Fierro Celested   /  1st District, Pangasinan

DISMISSED in Decision promulgated on February 24, 2022

19-013

 

Antonio H. Cerilles -v.- Leonardo L. Babasa,Jr.   /  2nd District, Zamboanga del Sur

DISMISSED in Decision promulgated on July 29, 2021

19-015

 

Luis R. Villafuerte represented by Lalaine Villafuerte-Abonal -v.- Gabriel H. Bordado,Jr.

 

DISMISSED in a Resolution promulgated on March 17, 2024

19-016

 

Dante S. Esguerra -v.- Sandra Young-Eriguel   /  2nd District, La Union

 

DISMISSED per Petitioner's Motion to Withdraw the Petition

19-017

Bryan M. Asuer -v.- Jose Antonio G. Lopez   /  MARINO Party List

DISMISSED for lack of Jurisdiction

19-018

Nurhaipa S. Berto -v.- Munir M. Arbison   /  2nd District, Sulu

DISMISSED per Protestant Motion to withdraw Election Protest

19-019

Harryking P. David -v.- Noel L. Villanueva  / 3rd District Tarlac

DISMISSED in a Resolution promulgated on September 24, 2020

19-020

Ephraim C. Genuino -v.- Ruth Mariano Hernandez   /  2nd District, Laguna

Petition for Quo Warranto is GRANTED, Petitioner Genuino is DECLARED the winner...

19-021

YACAP Partylist -v.- Sarah Jane Elago  /  KABATAAN Partylist

Dismissed per Resolution promulgated on March 18, 2021

19-022

Jejomar C. Binay -v.- Romulo V. Peña,Jr,   /  1st District, Makati City

Dismissed per Protestant Motion to Withdraw his Election Protest.

19-023

Henry C. Ong -v.- Lolita T. Javier   /  2nd District, Leyte

Dismissed for lack of clear and convincing evidence

19-024

Mark Llandro I. Mendoza -v.- Lianda B. Bolilia   /  4th District,  Batangas

Dismissed per protestant's Motion to Withdraw Instant Protest Case

19-025

Harlin C. Abayon -v.- Paul R. Daza   /  4th District, Northern Samar

Dismissed for being insufficient in form and substance

19-026

Roberto Felipe Mejia -v.- Marissa Lourdes M. Andaya  /  1st District Camarines Sur

Dismissed due to the death of Protestee

19-027

Meynardo T. Sabili -v.- Rosa Vilma T. Santos-Recto   /  6th District, Batangas

Dismissed per protestant's Motion to Withdraw Instant Protest Case

19-028 & 19-034

Noel T. Fabila -v.- Juan Fidel Felipe F. Nograles; Mary Ann T. Alonzo-Cruz -v.- Juan Fidel Felipe F. Nograles  / 2nd District, Rizal 

Dismissed in a Decision promulgated on June 9, 2022

19-029

Mary Ann Susano -v.- Mari Grace Preciosa M. Castelo  /  2nd District, Quezon City

Dismissed per protestant's Urgent Motion to Withdraw Amended Instant Protest Case

19-030

Ernesto Raoul Magtuto,Jr. -v.- Arnulf Bryan Fuentebella  /  4th District Camarines Sur

Dismissed per potestant's failure to pay required cash deposit within the prescribed period

19-031

Lydia T. Laborera -v.- Jose J. Teves,Jr.   / TGP Partylist 

Dismissed per DECISION promulgated on November 25, 2022

19-032

Ramon H. Durano VI -v,- Vincent Franco D. Frasco   / !st District, Cebu

Dismissed for failure to establish reasonable recovery during the revision and appreciation of ballots...

19-033

Jose L. Lobregat -v.- Cesar L. Ramirez,Jr.   /  1st District,  Zamboanga City

Dismissed per protestant's Motion to Withdraw Instant Protest Case

19-035

John G. Bautista, Ricardo C. Cutchon &  Lucas R. Florentino; Giogidi B. Aggabao -v.- Alyssa Sheena Pua Tan  /  4th District, Isabela

Dismissed in a Decision promulgated on June 9, 2022, MR likewise Dismissed...