After the May 13, 2013 National and Local Elections, a total of thirty-seven (37) election contests were filed before HRET, composed of ten (10) Petitions for Quo Warranto and twenty-seven (27) Election Protests.

As of March 15, 2016, the Tribunal had already decided, and/or disposed, with finality, ALL of the thirty-seven (37) election contests filed for 2013-2016 congressional term.

See a summary on the status of election contests filed for 2013-2016 congressional term here.


DECISIONS/ RESOLUTIONS


HRET Case No. 13-001
Acmad D. Omar vs. Abdullah D. Dimaporo
2nd District, Lanao del Norte
Dismissed per 09 June 2014 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-002
Angel S. Rodriguez vs. Aileen C. Radaza
Lone District, Lapulapu City
Dismissed per 13 July 2014 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-003
Tomas V. Apacible vs. Eilleen R. Ermita-Buhain
1st District, Batangas
Dimissed per 30 January 2014 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-004
Rogelio D. Pacquiao vs. Pedro B. Acharon, Jr.
1st District, South Cotabato
Dismissed per 28 November 2013 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-005
Jessie B. Castillo vs. Lani Mercado-Revilla
Lone District, Bacoor City
Dismissed per 09 June 2014 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-006
Mary Mitzi L. Cajayon vs. Edgar R. Erice
2nd District, Caloocan City
Dismissed per 18 March 2015 Decision
Motion for Reconsideration was denied per 03 August 2015 Resolution


HRET Case No. 13-007
Eduardo S. Matillano vs. Douglas S. Hagedorn
3rd District, Palawan
Dismissed per 30 January 2014 Resolution
Motion for Reconsideration was denied per 09 June 2014 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-008
Hans Roger S. Luna vs. Maria Jocelyn V. Bernos
Lone District, Abra
Dismissed per 19 September 2013 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-009
Jose Benjamin “Benjo” Benaldo vs. Rolando “Klarox” Uy
1st District, Cagayan de Oro City
Dismissed per 27 February 2014 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-010
Orlando M. Salatandre, Jr. vs. Roman T. Romulo
Lone District, Pasig City
Dismissed per 24 October 2013 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-011
Aurelio D. Gonzales, Jr. vs. Oscar R. Rodriguez
3rd District, Pampanga
Dismissed per 16 December 2013 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-012
Carlos L. Valdez, Jr. vs. Raden C. Sakaluran
1st District, Sultan Kudarat
Dismissed per 21 January 2016 Decision
Motion for Reconsideration was denied per 07 March 2016 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-013
Pauline Ann C. Villasenor vs. Wilfrido Mark M. Enverga
1st District, Quezon
Dismissed per 16 December 2013 Resolution 

HRET Case No. 13-014
Rodolfo G. Plaza vs. Evelyn P. Mellana
2nd District, Agusan del Sur
Dismissed per 16 December 2013 Resolution
Motion for Reconsideration was denied per 27 February 2014 Resolution


HRET Case No. 13-015
Emilio Bernardino L. Yulo III vs. Alejandro Y. Mirasol
5th District, Negros Occidental
Dismissed per 28 November 2013 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-016
Liwayway Vinzons-Chato vs. Elmer E. Panotes
2nd District, Camarines Norte
Dismissed per 23 February 2015 Decision

HRET Case No. 13-017
Rolando E. Yebes vs. Rosendo S. Labadlabad
2nd District, Zamboanga del Norte
Dismissed per 19 September 2013 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-018
Wigberto “Toby” R. Tanada, Jr. vs. Angelina “Helen” D. Tan
4th District, Quezon
Dismissed per 25 September 2014 ResolutionSee Concurring and Dissenting Opinion
Motion for Reconsideration was denied per 22 January 2015 Resolution
See also Wigberto “Toby” R. Tanada, Jr. vs. House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal, et al., G.R. No. 217012, March 1, 2016

HRET Case No. 13-019
Froilan A. Nagano vs. Magnolia Rosa C. Antonino-Nadres
4th District, Nueva Ecija
Dismissed per 28 November 2013 Decision

HRET Case No. 13-020
Luis Raymund F. Villafuerte, Jr. vs. Diosdado Ignacio Jose Maria M. Arroyo
2nd District, Camarines Sur
Dismissed per 28 November 2013 Resolution
Motion for Reconsideration was denied per 27 February 2014


HRET Case No. 13-021
Ariel “AGA” A. Muhlach vs. Felix William “Wimpy” Fuentebella
4th District, Camarines Sur
Dismissed per 28 August 2014 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-022
Mary Elizabeth Ty-Delgado vs. Philip Arreza Pichay
1st District, Surigao del Sur
Dismissed per 18 March 2015 Decision; See Dissenting Opinion
Motion for Reconsideration was denied per 27 February 2014 Resolution

See also Supreme Court Decision in Mary Elizabeth Ty-Delgado vs. House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal and Philip Arreza Pichay, G.R. No. 219603, January 26, 2016

HRET Case No. 13-023
Raul A. Daza vs. Harlin C. Abayon
1st District, Northern Samar
GRANTED per 03 February 2016 Decision; See Dissenting Opinion
Motion for Reconsideration was denied per 07 March 2016 Resolution
See also Supreme Court Decision in Harlin C. Abayon vs. House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal (HRET) and Raul A. Daza, G.R. Nos. 222236 and 223032, May 3, 2016

HRET Case No. 13-024
Solomon R. Chungalao vs. Teodoro B. Baguilat, Jr.
Lone District, Ifugao
Dismissed per 07 September 2015 Decision

HRET Case No. 13-025
Niel D. Tupas, Sr. vs. Hernan G. Biron, Jr.
4th District, Iloilo
Dismissed per 21 January 2016 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-026
Barbara Ruby C. Talaga vs. Vicente J. Alcala
2nd District, Quezon
Dismissed per 30 January 2014 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-027
Christopher P. Matienzo vs. Regina Ongsiako Reyes
Lone District, Marinduque
Dismissed per 30 January 2014 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-028
Lord Allan Jay Q. Velasco vs. Regina O. Reyes
Lone District, Marinduque
Dismissed per 28 November 2013 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-029
Faysah RPM Dumarpa vs. Ansaruddin A. Adiong
1st District, Lanao del Sur
Dismissed per 29 May 2014 Resolution
Motion for Reconsideration was denied per 31 July 2014 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-030
Jerome V. Paras Manuel M. Iway
1st District, Negros Oriental
Dismissed per 23 February 2015 Decision

HRET Case No. 13-031
Jun Omar C. Ebdane vs. Cheryl P. Deloso-Montalla
2nd District, Zambales
Dismissed per 16 December 2013 Resolution
Motion for Reconsideration was denied per 13 March 2014 Resolution


HRET Case No. 13-032
Richard Venancio Fernando V. Ziga vs. Edcel Lagman, Jr.
1st District, Albay
Dismissed per 15 August 2013 Resolution

HRET Case No. 13-033
Geraldine P. Yapha vs. Gwendolyn P. Garcia
3rd District, Cebu
Dismissed per 08 June 2015 Decision

HRET Case No. 13-034
Bertrand A. Baterina vs. Ronald V. Singson
1st District, Ilocos Sur
Dismissed per 15 August 2013 Resolution
Motion for Reconsideration was denied per 24 October 2013 Resolution 

HRET Case No. 13-035
Eduardo C. Morales vs. Johnny R. Revilla
Party List, OFWFC
Dismissed per 14 December 2015 Decision; See Concurring Opinion; See Dissenting Opinion
Motion for Reconsideration was denied per 07 March 2016 Resolution


HRET Case No. 13-036/ 13-037
Noeme Mayores Tan & Jesseca L. Mapacpac , Eric Del Mundo Junio
vs. Regina Ongsiako Reyes

Lone District, Marinduque
Dismissed per 28 November 2013 for insufficiency in form and substance

The petition-in-intervention arguing HRET's lack of jurisdiction was dismissed and the Tribunal directed the hearing and reception of evidence per 11 September 2014 Resolution; See
Dissenting Opinion


The 11 September 2014 Resolution was subsequently reversed and set aside and the petitions were dismissed per 14 December 2015 Resolution for lack of jurisdiction

Motion for Reconsideration was denied per 27 January 2016 Resolution

 
For inquiries, comments and suggestions kindly contact us thru:

Information System and Judicial Records Management Service
Rm. 301, 3rd Floor, Right Wing, Electoral Tribunal Building
Commonwealth Avenue, Quezon City
Tel. No. (+632) 931 7642
E-mail: isjrms@hret.gov.ph